Small-group tours to Southeast Asia: Are they worth the money?

KhosanRonaldThis site is meant to be a resource for independent travel around the world. In many of the most popular destinations, independent travel is as simple as it is rewarding, but not everywhere. Southeast Asia is a prime example of an area where it takes a great amount of work in order to guide yourself around with any confidence at all. So in a region like this, do small-group tour packages (10 to 15 people) really offer the best value?

The short answer for many people is that yes they do, but as usual, it’s more complicated than that. Most people can travel through Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam, and Laos for very little money (globally speaking). However, it’s almost guaranteed that you’ll get ripped off multiple times and will also spend many hours deep in a sea of confusion and frustration as you realize that you’ve missed some of the major things you’ve actually come to see.

How much do small-group tours cost in Southeast Asia?

VientianeMonksMany large companies offer a wide variety of small-group package tours all throughout Southeast Asia ranging from 4 to 30 days, and all of them tend to average about US$100 per day per person based on two sharing a room. This price does NOT include airfare to or from Southeast Asia, but it does include all transportation and attractions once you are there, plus most meals.

The best known tour operators are the international G Adventures and Intrepid Travel, but there are also regional specialists such as Geckos Adventures. All of them have similar products and similar prices.

  • Typical tour price: US$100 per day
  • Independent traveler price: US$25 to US$50 per day (in Southeast Asia)
  • Transportation between destinations: US$10 average

So independent travel is the winner, right? Not for most people, and below we’ll help you figure out which group you are in.

Independent travel in Southeast Asia is a challenge

HanoiTrafficEven though cities like Bangkok and Saigon are quite modern in many respects, they are also overflowing with hassles and difficulties. And once you get outside the major cities, things usually get even more complicated. Conquering these situations are part of the fun (or at least satisfaction) for many of us, but most people don’t go on holiday to “conquer” something and spend half their days solving problems.

Unlike most of the rest of the world, speaking English is quite rare in all of these countries. Sure, you can order food or buy a bottle of water in English anywhere you go, but if you need help choosing the best bus to your next stop or finding a place where someone can fix your broken laptop, you are usually out of luck.

Independent travel is much slower, for better or worse

Transportfield350Another key factor in whether an organized tour is better for you is the time it takes. If you look at a typical itinerary of a 2-week tour through Southeast Asia you’ll see perhaps 7 cities and 20 attractions. Trying to create that same itinerary on your own would probably take at least 3 weeks and will include a fair amount of stress.

The truth is, it takes several hours each day to organize bus or train journeys for long distances and to use public transportation to research and get to nearby attractions. It’s fair to say that independent travelers will take 50% more time to see the classic attractions that you’ve flown all that way to see. You can also say that independent travelers get to know these places at a deeper level during their trip. There is no right answer, but it is worth considering the trade-offs.

Organized tours are better value for the following types

If you are considering both options, the points below should help you decide whether an organized tour is actually best for you.

Those with 2 weeks or less to spend in Southeast Asia

VangViengLunchBeerIt can be very cheap to travel around Southeast Asia on your own if you have no set schedule. But if you have two weeks or less to spend there, then the efficiency and expertise of an organized tour is almost certainly worth it. As mentioned just above, you can see far more on a tour in a given time than you can on your own, period.

Unless you are starting within the region, it’s going to cost perhaps US$1,000 round-trip to get there and you probably won’t be back again for years, if ever. It makes financial sense to pack more sightseeing into your trip, especially when it’s in a well-planned and low-stress way like on a tour.

Travelers who prefer the social aspects of traveling

BeachMassageIndependent travelers can have active social lives while on the road, whether they are in a small group or even on their own. But it can’t really compare to the social aspect of traveling in a small-group tour. Indie travelers must spend hours each day just finding sights and each other, and when they go city to city they are usually surrounded by locals who speak little or no English.

On an organized tour you generally have people of a similar age and adventure level with you for at least portions of each day. You also have a tour guide who knows his or her way around and is experienced in getting guests to interact to the degree they are interested. As the tour goes on you also have shared experiences to discuss, so you always have someone to party with or just whisper with on the bus rides.

Young or inexperienced travelers

SinhCafeAs mentioned above, traveling around Southeast Asia is filled with challenges as well as outright scams. Try booking a Halong Bay tour on your own from an agency in Hanoi and you are almost certain to be lied to and ripped off to some degree. That is one of hundreds of key situations where quickly being able to figure out whom to trust and how much to trust them is critical.

In addition to all the other benefits, an organized tour is basically a lesson in how to travel safely. The chances of actual harm coming to independent travelers is very small, but the chances of getting ripped off or massively overcharged are pretty much 100%. After one major organized tour you’ll have a far better idea of how things work in “developing” parts of the world like Southeast Asia.

Conclusion: Tours provide great value for many travelers

HaLongBayThose of us who are serious cheapskates might struggle with this decision because on the surface it seems like tour operators are charging a heavy premium for something that we can accomplish on our own. We might also feel like we’ll be able to travel closer to the ground if we do all the research and make all of our own decisions. While those things might be true, it doesn’t mean it will be a cheaper or better holiday.

Some independent travelers look down on organized tour groups, but a tour might not sound so bad when they are stranded at a bus station in an obscure town with a similar name to the one they wanted to reach. If you want to get the most out of a trip and you don’t plan on spending months doing all the work, an organized tour is probably your best bet.



2 Responses to “Small-group tours to Southeast Asia: Are they worth the money?”

ucipass says:

I would have to disagree and provide a counter argument:

1.) You do not have to wait to start your activities at convenient times (8-5?) for a group. You can leave your hotel at 4AM or just get to your destination by midnight.
2.) You do not have to wait for other people to join your group or make several bathroom breaks.
3.) Your plans are flexible and can change anytime in case you discover something and want to stay at certain places for a long time or just skip the boring places and move onto the next interesting sight.

1.) example most Costa Rica group trips plan on staying in San Jose an extra day at arrival and departure days wasting almost a 2 days because they do not want to risk of being late or driving at nigh so on a 7 day trip all of a sudden becomes a 5 day trip.
3.) I have seen about 2-3 times as many sigths in Beijing doing it on my own than most day tours. The reason is because if something is not interesting you can just move on to the next one without having to stick to a daily plan.

 

    ucipass,

    You make some good points. I didn’t mean to imply that small-group tours are better in every way except the price, and there are certainly some downsides like those you mention. However, this article is about Southeast Asia, where almost nothing is easy on your own. In better organized places like Beijing or London it’s possible to move quickly independently, especially where there is a good public transportation system. But public transportation barely exists in the countries I’m discussing here, so having a minibus waiting to take you directly to the front door of your next thing is way faster.

    I’m a dedicated independent traveler and I actually enjoy figuring these things out. The point of this article is to discuss that paying more for a tour in Southeast Asia has many benefits that don’t apply in most of the rest of the world. Thanks for the comments. -Roger

     

Leave a Comment

    Name (required)
    Mail (will not be published) (required)
    Website